Court Finds Social Network Add-On Violated Spam, Hacking Laws

Court Finds Social Network Add-On Violated Spam, Hacking Laws

In a potentially troublesome decision, a federal district court has found that a start-up violated anti-spam and computer crime laws by creating and marketing a browser to let users view their social networking accounts in one place. The case demonstrates the difficulties facing those who seek to empower users to interact with closed services like Facebook in new and innovative ways.

In Facebook v. Power Ventures, Facebook sued a small company that created a tool for users to access and aggregate their personal information across social networking sites. In 2010, the court ruled that Power didn’t access Facebook “without permission” under California computer crime law when it violated Facebook’s terms of use, agreeing with arguments we raised in an amicus brief (pdf).

Unfortunately, the latest round of the case has taken a downward turn in ways that could have serious implications for other innovators and users.

First, the court gave a tremendous cudgel to Facebook against commercial users who displease it when it decided that Power violated the federal CAN-SPAM Act by sending “misleading” messages. These messages encouraged users to send Facebook “Event” invitations to their friends to promote Power’s service. As EFF pointed out in an amicus brief (pdf), though, the allegedly “misleading” elements of the message are supplied by Facebook itself—and can’t be changed by users. This means that any user who sends a commercial message on Facebook is technically in violation of the law, since it appears to come from Facebook. The CAN-SPAM Act, passed in 2003, simply doesn’t contemplate closed systems where the service provider controls many elements of a message.                  More

wordpress visitor counter

Get Free Email Updates!

Signup Now to Receive Updates and Alerts!

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


Candice writes for several publications, including The Christian Post, Red State, The Black Sphere and Patriot Update. She is the Science & Tech Editor at the Minority Report Blog and the founder and Editor-in-Chief at Front Lines. She's also the founder of Candice Lanier's Tech News and works as a computer consultant. Additionally, Candice is an antiques dealer.

More in


Female professor found GUILTY of raping mute, cerebral palsy-stricken, diaper-wearing man

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

Do You Agree Brilliant Meme Perfectly Captures Obama’s Sick, Twisted Gun Control Agenda

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

Islamic Indoctrination Embedded In Common Core and These Parents Won’t Have It

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

This State bans baby parts sales, cuts funding from groups that do abortions

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

WHAT? Pedophile are demanding “equal rights”…

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

Magic pill mimics the effects of exercise without the hard work Soon Available

Sela TangataevahaOct 4, 2015

The Minority Report is a network of websites devoted to Conservative & Libertarian politics in the United States. In 2014 the network had over 20 million page views!

On this site you'll find posts & links to some of the best and most comprehensive center-right news and opinion on the net...

February 2012
« Jan   Mar »


Copyright © 2014 The Minority Report Network