Kansas Supreme Court Attempts to Dictate National Antitrust Policy

Kansas Supreme Court Attempts to Dictate National Antitrust Policy

(By Ted Frank, adjunct fellow with the Center for Legal Policy at the Manhattan Institute)

As we discussed in 2007, the U.S. Supreme Court in Leegin recognized that it was economically irrational to treat “resale price maintenance” as a per se violation of the antitrust laws, especially given existing jurisprudence recognizing economically equivalent vertical restraints as a benefit to consumers. (See also my AEI discussion; Overlawyered.)

But that hasn’t stopped the plaintiffs’ bar from forum-shopping for courts that might ignore economic reality in favor of soaking out-of-state defendants. Last week, they hit paydirt with another lawsuit against Leegin Creative Leather Products, as the Kansas Supreme Court held resale price maintenance per se illegal. But the decision goes beyond that, arguing that Kansas law holds other so-called restraints on trade illegal, even when adjudged “reasonable” (i.e., beneficial to consumers) by federal antitrust standards.

Such a rule would effectively hold illegal common business practices recognized as proper for decades, and would be a pure wealth transfer from society to lawyers, and from out-of-state businesses and consumers to Kansas. It would force interstate businesses who could not readily operate differently in Kansas than in the rest of the country to change their practices, to the detriment of consumers in all fifty states. It’s not just bad policy, but an impingement on interstate commerce and should be held a violation of the Commerce Clause for its attempt to expropriate the benefits of interstate commerce. One hopes defendant Leegin gets the U.S. Supreme Court involved; one also hopes that the Kansas legislature fixes this mess as quickly as possible before the state becomes a judicial hellhole.

Get Free Email Updates!

Signup Now to Receive Updates and Alerts!

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

@stevenfoley

A former U.S.Marine, he is the Creator of The Minority Report Network. He is also the Founder and Managing Editor of the Network’s flagship site, www.theminorityreportblog.com, Former Director of New Media for Liberty.com, Former Director of New Media for Liberty First PAC, and the Former Chief Managing Editor of 73Wire.com. Steve is a well respected national conservative blogger who’s dedicated the past several years of his life advancing conservatism online. Recently Steve was instrumental in the development of Liberty.com, Liberty First PAC, The Patriot Caucus, the national campaign trail and grassroots news site73wire.com.

More in

15-0328 Gay Mafia

Gay Groups That Want Christianity Outlawed are Furious at this Governor

Michael BeckerMar 30, 2015
15-0328 Guns DC

Marco Rubio Introduces Bill to End D.C.’s Strict Anti-Gun Laws

Michael BeckerMar 30, 2015
branco-blackberry-whine-hillary-email-2

Another Murky Mystery Surrounding Hillary’s Private Email

Steve FoleyMar 30, 2015
chevron_texaco_400_200_mini

Chevron/Ecuador Video: The “Legal Fraud of the Century” in 3 Minutes

Steve FoleyMar 30, 2015
US-POLITICS-CONGRESS-BUDGET

The Budget: A Return To Regular Order

Steve FoleyMar 30, 2015
Divided America

Outrage: Supreme Court Denies Certiorari in American Flag – Cinco de Mayo Case

Steve FoleyMar 30, 2015

The Minority Report is a network of websites devoted to Conservative & Libertarian politics in the United States. In 2014 the network had over 20 million page views!

On this site you'll find posts & links to some of the best and most comprehensive center-right news and opinion on the net...

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr   Jun »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

Archives

Copyright © 2014 The Minority Report Network