Are 401(k)’s Headed Towards the Cliff?

Are 401(k)’s Headed Towards the Cliff?

Cliffs_of_Dover-Michael Rowe wiki

The political classes are talking about 401(k) savings plans. This should make one nervous, because the buzz is not about getting people to save more. The federal government, addicted to its big-spending ways, needs new sources of revenue. The tax deferral feature of 401(k) plans is a potential target, and there is increasing chatter about capping eligible contributions.

Brett Goldstein, director of retirement planning for American Investment Planners, discussed the “20-20 cap” plan in an interview with AdvisorOne :

Employees would be able to contribute the lesser of $20,000 or 20% of their pay. An employee earning $50,000, for example, could contribute as much as $10,000–inclusive of the company match, which Goldstein says is typically 4%, or $2,000.

That means this employee could contribute just $8,000, or 54% less than the $17,500 that current law allows.

Owners of small businesses, who generally have more income than their employees, would be hit harder by caps. This disincentive might tempt them to shut down their 401(k) plans altogether. They could turn to a combination of IRA’s and annuities to accomplish their savings goals, while saving on plan administrative costs. The net result would likely be less savings by employers and employees, fewer choices and more confusion across the board.

One would be hard pressed to argue, after examining the stretched finances of American households and their meager preparation for retirement, that excess saving is the number one problem facing the American economy. But Washington DC is hungry for cash, and that does not bode well for prudent policy choices.

Caveat lector!

Get Free Email Updates!

Signup Now to Receive Updates and Alerts!

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.


Retired from American Airlines after a 34 year career in corporate treasury management. Professional income tax preparer. Graduate of Georgetown University (BS Foreign Service) and The University of Texas at Arlington (MBA). Contributor to TMR since 2007. Host of "Italian Tomatoes" show on Blog Talk Radio. I am a center-right Republican with a passion for business, history and current affairs. Go to Blog Talk Radio to listen to my latest show Why Jeb Bush Is Not The One

More in


A Restriction on Congressional Salaries

Frank McHaleMay 27, 2015
15-0527 Bush Lied

Bush is Vindicated on WMDs – NY Times Admits It

Michael BeckerMay 27, 2015
15-0527 Diets

I’m Starting a New Diet.. Wait – I’ve Been on This One For Years!

Michael BeckerMay 27, 2015

Heritage: In ‘Tomorrowland,’ We Get a Glimpse of the Left’s Vision for the Future

Steve FoleyMay 27, 2015
nra leadership forum

Sen. Cruz Receives Bipartisan Support for NDAA Amendments

Steve FoleyMay 27, 2015

Minimum Wage Increases=Minimum Jobs

Steve FoleyMay 27, 2015

The Minority Report is a network of websites devoted to Conservative & Libertarian politics in the United States. In 2014 the network had over 20 million page views!

On this site you'll find posts & links to some of the best and most comprehensive center-right news and opinion on the net...

December 2012
« Nov   Jan »


Copyright © 2014 The Minority Report Network