CA Court Urged to Ignore Ideological Junk Science in Prop. 8

CA Court Urged to Ignore Ideological Junk Science in Prop. 8

ACRU-Authored Brief Warns Court to Avoid Ideologically Driven Research in Marriage Case

 

(Washington, DC) In a brief filed at the U.S. Supreme Court on Jan. 29 in the California Proposition 8 marriage case, co-author Ken Klukowski, a Senior Legal Analyst for the American Civil Rights Union (ACRU), argues that the Court should be leery of depending on social science to come to a verdict.

In Hollingsworth v. Perry, the court will decide whether the people of California can amend their state constitution to define marriage as the union of one man and one woman. California voters did this in 2008, prompting legal challenges that have made their way to the high court.

“This case should be decided on the basis of the law, without reliance on the social science studies and authorities that Respondents and their amici will undoubtedly put before the Court,” the brief states. Written by Mr. Klukowski and George Mason University Law Prof. Nelson Lund on behalf of Leon R. Kass, Harvey C. Mansfield and the Institute for Marriage and Public Policy, the brief states:

“The social and behavioral sciences have a long history of being shaped and driven by politics and ideology. This is partly because researchers often choose to study issues implicating controversial questions of public policy. And it is partly because it is often impossible to perform the kind of objective observations and controlled experiments that are standard in the physical sciences.”

The brief further notes that, “History is littered with notorious examples of false theories gaining wide acceptance among respected social and behavioral scientists, some of which supported pernicious public policies.

“There is good reason to believe that the political climate has strongly influenced much of the existing research on issues raised in this case. That body of research, moreover, is radically inconclusive. Same-sex marriage is a very recent innovation, as is the practice of child rearing by same-sex couples. The effects of these new developments could certainly be significant. But only an advocate for social change could claim to know that the effects will be entirely or even largely benign.”

Get Free Email Updates!

Signup Now to Receive Updates and Alerts!

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

@stevenfoley

A former U.S.Marine, he is the Creator of The Minority Report Network. He is also the Founder and Managing Editor of the Network’s flagship site, www.theminorityreportblog.com, Former Director of New Media for Liberty.com, Former Director of New Media for Liberty First PAC, and the Former Chief Managing Editor of 73Wire.com. Steve is a well respected national conservative blogger who’s dedicated the past several years of his life advancing conservatism online. Recently Steve was instrumental in the development of Liberty.com, Liberty First PAC, The Patriot Caucus, the national campaign trail and grassroots news site73wire.com.

More in

952

Killed in Airstrike: Top ISIS Hacker On Pentagon Hit List Who Threatened Attacks on US Military

Candice LanierAug 27, 2015
The Goldman Sachs & Co. logo is displayed at the company's booth on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York, U.S., on Friday, July 19, 2013. U.S. stocks fell after benchmark equities gauges rose to records yesterday, after disappointing earnings from Google Inc. and Microsoft Corp. overshadowed better-than-forecast results from General Electric Co. Photographer: Scott Eells/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Somebody in China Has Set Up a Fake Goldman Sachs and Is Doing Business

Candice LanierAug 27, 2015
hillary organge 1

White House Insiders Track Move From Hillary To Warren

Streetwise_ITAug 25, 2015
940

Legal showdown looms over the NCAA’s ban on paying athletes

Candice LanierAug 24, 2015
trump 081115

The Donald- Not Exactly A Fan Of “New Tone”

Streetwise_ITAug 21, 2015
viewers view emails

EmailGate- The Sisters Have A Question

Streetwise_ITAug 18, 2015

The Minority Report is a network of websites devoted to Conservative & Libertarian politics in the United States. In 2014 the network had over 20 million page views!

On this site you'll find posts & links to some of the best and most comprehensive center-right news and opinion on the net...

February 2013
M T W T F S S
« Jan   Mar »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728  

Archives

Copyright © 2014 The Minority Report Network