McCain urges UK-style sessions for U.S. president

Tagged:

From Reuters

Republican presidential candidate John McCain said on Thursday that, if elected, he would like to take a page from the British government and appear in question-and-answer sessions with lawmakers.

"I will ask Congress to grant me the privilege of coming before both houses to take questions, and address criticism, much the same as the prime minister of Great Britain appears regularly before the House of Commons," McCain said in excerpts of a speech he is to deliver later in Columbus, Ohio.

Although U.S. presidents deliver annual "State of the Union" speeches to Congress at the start of each year, those formal addresses do not include a question-and-answer session

I still haven't digested this one yet but it seems like a horrible idea.

First, granting some first term loony Senator or Congressmen access to question the POTUS (which will quickly delude into a 10 min diatribe on his pet grievance) will prove to be a complete waste of time!

Second, If McCain wants to take questions he should invite both party's leadership to a regular meeting at the White House where they can ask questions from their members on his terms and turf.

This could turn into a political nightmare!

DocJ - chiming in: I'm with you on this one, Steve - this is a God-awful horrible idea. We don't have a parlimentary system and I hate that we're already well on our way to the Judiciary becoming a "super-legislature" - further bluring of the lines between the branches is beyond counterproductive.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Brian Simpson's picture
It would give McCain a chance to be seen on TV many times a week taking on his critics in Congress. He would use the bully pulpit in the ways that we have been hoping President Bush would have these last 7+ years.
Fighting for conservatism one day at a time.
DocJ's picture

Then he'd be taking-on the congressional Repblicans. Weekly. Can't see that as being helpful, really.

Oh, and Bush doing a version of "Prime Ministers Questions"? Thanks, but I'll pass.

---------
Diplomacy is the art of saying 'Nice doggie' until you can find a rock.

Brian Simpson's picture
I actually found Bush was at his best when he was confronting people off the cuff like the reporter from a couple of weeks ago.

And yes, I do think this would be one area where McCain would be taking on Congressional Republicans. I mean, you can't tell me that you think that the Rs have been all that great on spending. I would cheer Johnnie Mc whenever he took on the porkers.
Fighting for conservatism one day at a time.
DocJ's picture

Bush, off the cuff and unscripted, weekly, with cameras rolling, for an hour at a shot, with entire staffs of congresscritters looking to get him to say something silly...

Sorry, I still pass.

Maverick gets his knickers in a twist over a $150K earmark but berates anyone who won't sign-on to his McAmnesty or multi-trillion-dollar cap-and-trade scheme. Oh yeah, that's what I want to see on a weekly basis.

Sorry man, double pass.

---------
Diplomacy is the art of saying 'Nice doggie' until you can find a rock.

BlackMaverick's picture

Earmarks are a hot dog in a hallway compared to the price of McCain worshiping in Al Gore's church.

The trouble with our friend John McCain isn't that he's ignorant, it just that he knows so much that isn't so.

Steve Foley's picture

...my second suggestion

Steve Foley's picture

He could appoint himself king while he's at it!

King McCain the I of America and Prime Minister Hilary Clinton since he' seems to be so enamored with her!

I think he's foolish to announce it as a regular thing. If it goes badly, and it could really go badly, he looks even worse for canceling it.

As to whether it's a good idea or not, I think it would cheapen the office, and give the media a weekly chance to say just how badly he's doing.

It points to a more serious problem: McCain may still be under the impression that he has friends in the media. If that's the case, then he will lose in November ... and badly.

- Help annoy moonbats even more with 'Socrates' at the Academy.
Steve Foley's picture